I originally posted this on June 7, 2009. The photo did not come close to doing this macaroni salad justice, so I’ve replaced the one, lone, sad photo with some that I hope will make your stomach growl just a little!
I do enjoy a good pasta salad: crisp, blanched vegetables and yummy al dente pasta shapes all drenched in a homemade vinaigrette and spiked with whatever herbs and spices strike my fancy.
But that’s not what I’m here to talk about. This is Macaroni Salad. I can’t even call it pasta salad, because it isn’t Schmancy enough.
This is the macaroni that you take to the covered dish Wednesday night supper. The one that you make for the little league end-of-season party. The Dish of Choice for the swim team party, the block party, the I’m-sorry-your-aunt-died get together. I grew up eating this stuff, and when I make it for myself, I stay pretty true to Mom’s way of making it. And now, I’m going to share it with you.
Use this as a basic recipe template, and feel free to add/substitute to your Heart’s Content. But do try it The Original Way at least once. Especially if you are a fan of celery seed and tuna. You won’t be sorry.
Here it is. My mom’s macaroni salad, and my favorite macaroni salad in all the land.
If you love the sound of this nostalgic recipe, please rate and/or comment. I love hearing from you! And if you make this (and make it your own), please share it with me on Instagram at @onlinepastrychef using hashtag #pcorecipe or share it in the Pastry Chef Online Facebook Group. Can’t wait to see!
I never measure when I make this. The whole idea is to make enough dressing goo to coat all the pasta pretty liberally. By the next day, most of it will have soaked in, leaving the pasta somewhat dry. If you don't like it that way, make a Very Lot of dressing goo. If you like your macaroni on the dry-ish side, make Just Enough. Whatever that means is up to you.
I will give you amounts to start with, and from there you can add more or less as your taste dictates. Enjoy!
- 1 cups mayonnaise
- 1 cup sour cream
- 2 Tablespoons spicy mustard
- salt to taste
- pepper to taste
- 3 Tablespoons vinegar I like apple cider vinegar for this
- 1 teaspoon celery seed
- 1 Tablespoon sugar or honey (optional)
- 1 pound macaroni--shells or elbows. You can use Special Shapes , but I stay with the basic Loved Since Childhood shapes for this one
- 1 cup medium onion , diced (as much or as little as you like)
- 2 ribs celery , small dice (ditto)
- 1/2 cup dill pickles , all cut up into wee cubes. Or just use relish. (double ditto)
- 12 oz canned tuna drained and pressed
- 1/2 cup cheddar cheese cut into 1/4" cubes (I also used some pepper jack, because it said it wanted to join the party. Who was I to say no)? (triple ditto)
- Mix equal parts mayonnaise and sour cream.
- Add in enough mustard so that the whole deal is decidedly yellow-ish.
Season with salt and pepper, and add enough vinegar to make it the consistency of thick-ish ranch dressing.
- Add about 1/2-1 tsp celery seed (depending on how much you like it. Remember, you can use whatever you want). Stir and stir, and taste.
- You might need to add a squirt of honey or other sweetener if it's tasting a little too Pointy to you. I like it pointy, so I skip the sweetener.
When I was done, I probably had about 2 cups of dressing. Make more or less, depending upon how gooey you like your macaroni. Oh, yeah--if you want, you can add some grated Parmesan to your dressing. I didn't this time (and I didn't miss it), but I've done that before, and it is Very Good.
- Cook the macaroni until it is done to your liking, and drain well.
- Put the macaroni into a big old bowl, and stir in the dressing. Yes, while the macaroni is still hot, so it will soak in.
- Then, stir in the onion, celery, pickles and tuna until it is all nicely Mixed Up. I do this one ingredient at a time, just to give the macaroni time to cool off some before adding the cheese.
- Add the cheese cubes last.
- Refrigerate until cold.
- Put in your face.
- Mom used to put in shredded carrot, and you can if you want. I don't. You can leave out the tuna, or substitute chicken, if you want. You can also add in chopped herbs if you feel called to do so.
Do you have a favorite “mom-style” dish that you go back to again and again? I’d love to hear about it so I can make it and Eat It. And maybe share with The Beloved.
And if you love creamy, comforting, hot pasta dishes, try my one-pot pimento cheese pasta. You will be so happy!