Streusel Recipe | How to Make Streusel

Why Make This Recipe?

It seems a little ridiculous to say that my streusel recipe is better than anyone else’s.

At the end of the day, streusel is pretty much streusel, no matter how you slice it.

I do hope that you will come away with some more ideas for ways of using streusel, for more ways of flavoring it, and with permission to play with proportions so you get the streusel of your dreams!

Basic Streusel

At its most basic, make streusel with equal parts butter and sugar and twice as much flour, plus a healthy pinch of salt.

For example, if you’re using 4 oz each of butter and sugar, you’ll need 8 oz of flour.

This recipe scales up beautifully, so you can even make a ton of streusel mix, divide it into portions (your call how big those portions are) and pull it out when you need to top a buckle or some muffins.

Let your portion thaw, and then add desired mix-ins or use it straight up.

Mixing

You will only need to bring out your mixer if you’re making a ton of streusel.

Otherwise, you just need a bowl and your fingers.

Here’s what you’ll do.

1. Scale out your ingredients. In the first photo, you can see I’m using half brown sugar and half white sugar, butter, flour, and a healthy pinch of salt.
2. Place all the ingredients in a bowl.
3. Rub the butter into the flour, sugars, and salt until completely combined and crumbly.
4. For folks who prefer volume measurements, the fourth photo shows the approximate volume of streusel you’ll get from this recipe. The top measure is a 1 1/2 cup measure and the smaller, bottom one is a 1/2 cup measure. The total volume is about 1 3/4 cups, which is enough to generously top 12 blueberry muffins.

Streusel Variations

Lots of people consider streusel an afterthought, but you can pack in so much extra flavor and texture that I consider it integral to the overall flavor and texture of a recipe.

Here are some mix-in ideas you may never have considered before. I’ll also add ideas that you probably have considered before.

• Spices: cinnamon, nutmeg, ginger, etc, or a blend like pumpkin pie spice or spiced vanilla sugar
• Cocoa nibs: for crunch and delicious chocolate flavor
• Zest: orange zest or lemon zest. Even lime zest–think of a coconut muffin with some lime zesty streusel. Mmmmm….
• Seeds, Grains, and Alternate Flours: Add chopped toasted pepitas, sunflower seeds, sesame seeds, oatmeal, rolled quinoa, etc. Sub in some whole wheat flour or even rye flour for a portion of your all-purpose flour. You could even add a bit of cornmeal. Think sweet corn muffins with crumbly cornmeal streusel on top.
• Alternate sugar: Even if you’re not keto, you may not want the extra sugar in streusel, so this is a great place to sub in some Swerve or Lakanto Monkfruit sweetener. I often do that when I am kind of sugared out. And even if you don’t want to use a sugar substitute, you can also use some powdered sugar for some or all of your granulated and/or brown sugar. The little bit of cornstarch in powdered sugar can help up the crispy factor even though the crumbs themselves are more delicate
• Extracts: Feel free to add a little vanilla extract, orange oil, maple extract, or coffee extract to your streusel. Whatever flavor will complement what you’re topping with streusel is fair game
• Toasted, chopped nuts: Personally, I would chop any nuts really finely, but you can leave them in larger pieces. Again, it’s totally dependent upon what you’re topping and if you think larger nuts will add to the overall Deliciousness factor. Think pecans, walnuts, hazelnuts, cashews, pistachios, or peanuts
• Dried fruits: including minced crystallized ginger. Which isn’t a fruit, but still.
• Unconventional Mix-Ins: Finely chopped crisp bacon, a little preserved lemon, a tiny bit of honey, sorghum, or pomegranate molasses. Maybe some pinenuts. A little spicy spice like cayenne or ground chipotle could also work when applied very judiciously. Maybe some shredded coconut. Honestly, pretty much anything that could find its way into granola can also find its way into streusel.

Example Flavor Combinations

These are off the top of my head. Come up with your own combinations off the top of your head based on your taste, what you’re making, and what you have on hand.

Remember, basic streusel is better than no streusel, so go forth with confidence.

• Top orange muffins with streusel containing a little cardamom, orange zest, and finely chopped toasted pistachios
• Top a mocha snack cake with streusel, adding cocoa nibs, a little espresso powder, and cinnamon
• Top baked maple donuts with a Very Lot of brown sugar streusel with a touch of maple extract and chopped bacon
• Top an apple cake with streusel with toasted and chopped walnuts or pecans, apple pie spice, minced crystallized ginger, and some minced dried apple chips

Some Recipes Using Streusel

Just because the recipe you’re making doesn’t call for streusel doesn’t mean you can’t add some if it will elevate the whole recipe.

For example, if you are making a muffin recipe that just calls for a glaze–or no topping at all–bust out some streusel.

Here are some more of my recipes and my friends’ recipes that call for streusel. Know that you can use this recipe–these proportions–rather than using the specific streusel called for in each recipe.

• This caramel pumpkin mousse has a cocoa nib streusel to add extra flavor but also crunchy texture.
• Shoofly Pie has a layer of lean streusel mixed into and topping the filling. By “lean,” I mean that it has relatively little butter compared to the sugar and flour.
• My chocolate babka has a delicious streusel on top. Plus 2 glazes!
• These cherry muffins have a lovely, crisp topping of almond streusel.
• This peach crisp has lots of tasty oatmeal streusel providing the crispy goodness.

A Note About Measurements

NOTE: Most of my recipes are written by weight and not volume, even the liquids.

Even though I try to provide you with volume measurements as well, I encourage you to buy a kitchen scale for ease of measuring, accuracy, and consistency.

This is the scale I use, love, and recommend. If you’re unsure, please read my post about how to use a food scale.

I hope you enjoy this all-purpose streusel recipe. I know you’ll find many ways to use it.

Thanks for spending some time with me today.

Take care, and have a lovely day.