The Best Old Fashioned Hot Fudge Sauce in the World

Love This? Please Share It!

Reader Rave!

This is a superb hot fudge sauce recipe! I have made it twice now. I found I did not need to strain the sauce as it is pretty smooth as is. It is a very easy recipe to follow with big flavour!

Reader C. Teshima

What makes this the best?

This ice cream sauce is not the best because it has the fewest ingredients. No, that prize goes to good old ganache which makes a fine ice cream topping, clocking in at 2 or maybe 3 ingredients.

If you’re looking for good, old-fashioned hot fudge sauce, though, you need look no further.

Here are the things that make this fudge sauce the best:

• It gets a thick and a bit chewy when cold.
• You have to heat up in order to pour it.
• It has deep, rich flavor that is exactly what is needed to set off a perfect vanilla ice cream. Or coffee ice cream.
• There is enough salt in it to round out the flavors, counteract any bitterness that might be present if you use a really dark chocolate and to make the sauce sparkle on your tongue. 
• You can vary the flavor based on your preferences.

It is truly an old fashioned fudge sauce with deep, rich chocolate flavor.

How can I vary this recipe?

This sauce can be flavored in many ways. Here are some ideas to try:

• Add a bit of orange zest and/or cinnamon to the boil
• Switch out the rum for orange liqueur.
• Use your favorite alcohol–a liquor or liqueur.
• Add some peppermint extract.
• Whisk in powdered freeze-dried raspberries or other freeze-dried fruits.
• Add some heat in the form of chipotle pepper or smoked hot paprika

Play with this sauce and make it your own.

When you want to relive your visits to the soda fountain where the fudge sauce was thick and rich and tasted of fudge and not “brown,” then please make it according to the original recipe which calls for light rum and vanilla.

Ways to use it

Aside from pouring it over ice cream, you can also use the sauce to make chocolate milk or hot chocolate. Just stir enough into hot or cold milk until you like the chocolate-ness level and enjoy.

Here are some other ideas:

• Top a cheesecake with it
• Serve it with cake or drizzle it over an iced cake to get that “drip” effect
• Use it as the fudge layer in my chocolate cheesecake pie (Please do this!)
• Use it to layer with soft ice cream before freezing to make a swirled ice cream
• Top an ice cream mud pie like my friend Laura did
• Make chocolate pound cake or some fudgy brownies, top with a scoop of ice cream, and then drench the whole shebang with fudge sauce
• Even though you might want to eat it straight from a spoon, consider making some chocolate pudding instead!

Rave review

Laura Schrock made this recipe and shared her photo on Instagram!

Divine!!! Is the word that best describes this Hot fudge sauce. I was looking for a recipe for one this morning and stumbled upon this on on my Pinterest account and my word I will not be looking for another any time soon. Do yourself a favor and give it a try , I’ll post the link here in my bio 👍🏼Thank you @onlinepastrychef for the amazing recipe!❤️

Laura Schrock from Food In The Myakka Kitchen

I am so excited that she made and loved it, and I know you’ll love it too!

Ingredients

NOTE: Please keep scrolling down to the bottom of the post for the full recipe. In this section, I’m just letting you know what you’ll need.

The ingredient list is actually relatively long, but the process is pretty straightforward. Here’s what you’ll need:

• butter: the fat helps to carry the flavor and provide body. If you don’t have unsalted butter, use salted, but you may have to dial back amount of additional salt you use
• sugar: provides the sweetness and helps to give the sauce the traditional “chewy” texture of old time soda fountain hot fudge sauce. You can substitute light brown sugar, 1:1, if you would rather
• corn syrup: light or dark. Helps to prevent crystallization and provides more of the chewy texture we’re going for
• heavy cream: provides body and volume as well as additional milk fat. The dairy solids in the cream will brown as you cook the base, adding to flavor complexity
• salt: enhances the flavor and counteracts any bitterness from the cocoa powder
• milk: provides more volume without adding much additional fat. Also adds more dairy solids that will brown as they cook
• cocoa powder: provides the chocolate flavor. Use the best quality you can get, although honestly any will do. I make mine with Hershey’s and it’s fantastic
• water (or coffee): gives you something to make the cocoa powder paste with. If you use coffee, it will help to deepen the chocolate flavor just a touch
• light rum: adds enough alcohol to bring out alcohol soluble flavors without being a prominent flavor itself. You can certainly sub in your favorite liquor or liqueur here, depending on what flavor you’re going for
• vanilla: chocolate’s complement. Must have! You don’t have to use the top quality stuff, but adding vanilla helps to round out the flavors
• semi-sweet or bittersweet chocolate: adds additional chocolate flavor plus some cocoa butter for body

Why is there alcohol in this ice cream sauce?

Even just a bit of alcohol, whether it be rum or Kahlua or Godiva chocolate or whatever, brings out the alcohol soluble flavors that would otherwise remain locked away.

The entire recipe, and it makes just over a quart, uses only 2 Tablespoons of alcohol. You can’t taste it, but you would miss it were it not there.

Thank you so much for this recipe–I made a batch and LOVE it!

I **think** that I undercooked the dairy mixture–I was afraid of scorching it–I will bravely let it go another few shades darker next time in order to get the “chewy” factor. I also made bomb hot chocolate using it!

Reader Tangela

What can I substitute for the alcohol?

Since you add the boiled mixture to the alcohol mixture off the heat, none of the alcohol boils away. And even if you do boil it, while most will boil off, not all will.

If for any reason you cannot have alcohol, you can substitute 2 Tablespoons of very strong coffee.

Tools and equipment you might need

I always advocate for weighing your ingredients. It allows for consistent results. I love my Escali Primo and after 17 years, it is still going strong.

You’ll also need a large, heavy bottomed sauce pan, a nice large bowl for mixing up the cocoa paste, and a fine mesh strainer.

Another Rave Review!

I’m allergic to cocoa powder, so I made this for my friends and husband. They said YES! It is the best fudge sauce they have ever had!

Pinner Amber

Procedure

The process for making this sauce is pretty straightforward:

1. Bring butter, sugar, corn syrup, heavy cream, salt, and milk to a boil.
2. Whisk cocoa powder, rum, water (coffee) and vanilla into a paste.
3. Add the chopped chocolate/chocolate chips to a bowl along with the cocoa paste.
4. Let the sugar/milk mixture boil until a light caramel color, stirring frequently.
5. Pour the caramelized sugar/milk mixture into the bowl with the rest of the ingredients. Whisk until smooth.
6. Strain and store.

Do I have to caramelize the dairy mixture?

No, you don’t. But if you don’t take the 20-30 minutes to cook the dairy until it has caramelized, you will not have made the best hot fudge sauce in the world.

You will have made a very good one, but it won’t be the best.

Caramelizing the sugar/dairy does a couple of things:

• It evaporates out some of the water, concentrating the flavor and allowing for a thicker sauce and that old-fashioned chewy texture that is so incredibly addictive.
• The caramelized sugar and milk solids lend a deep, complex base flavor that you would not get if you don’t take this step.

Can’t I just buy some at the store?

Well, yes, you could. And I’m sure you can find one you really like.

However, I encourage you to make your own. If you don’t have time to boil a big old pot of ingredients on the stove for a long time, you can just make some ganache.

I also recommend trying my Quick Hot Fudge Sauce Recipe that takes a couple of shortcuts to get to long-cooked flavor in way less time.

You could also try this great quickie version from my friend Chris. It’s an excellent blender hot fudge sauce, so it comes together super fast.

And if you want to go really old school, make some chocolate syrup. I swear it is So Good either on ice cream or in chocolate milk.

Enough talk! Please go and make some of this sauce. And then come back and tell me how much you love it. Make a sundae, and don’t forget to put the cherry on top. I promise you will feel just like a kid again.

If you do make some, please share a photo with me, either in the PCO Facebook Group or on instagram by tagging @onlinepastrychef and using hashtag #pcorecipe. Thanks, and enjoy!

And if you have any questions about this recipe or any baking/pastry issues, please get in touch. You can comment here, or shoot me an email. I promise to get back in touch quickly. Honest!

A Note About Measurements

NOTE: Most of my recipes are written by weight and not volume, even the liquids. Even though I try to provide you with volume measurements as well, I encourage you to buy a kitchen scale for ease of measuring, accuracy, and consistency.

This is the scale I use, love, and recommend:

Thank you for spending some time with me today.

Enjoy the fudge sauce, and have a lovely day.

Love This? Please Share It!