The Best Chocolate Pound Cake | My Mom’s Recipe

Watch my chocolate pound cake web story here.

So far I’ve made Jenni’s chocolate pound cake twice. What a great recipe! I followed Jenni’s instructions all the way through and now I have a recipe I am proud to serve.

Reader and Pound Cake Lover Susan

And here’s a photo of Susan’s cake, used with permission. Look how beautiful!

What Makes This Recipe So Great

This was my Aunt Charlotte’s favorite cake. Mom used to make her one every year, and every year, this sainted woman hoarded it, only sharing see-through thin pieces with special friends and only when asked.

That alone should be enough of an endorsement, but since you didn’t know my sainted Aunt Charlotte, here are some more reasons:

• Using brown sugar deepens the flavor and also makes this cake moister so that it gets fudgy after a few days on the counter. If it lasts that long
• It has just enough instant coffee in it to bolster the chocolate without being mocha. (If you want a more coffee-forward pound cake, try my chocolate espresso pound cake)
• Adding acidic dairy (in the form of sour cream or buttermilk) makes the crumb nice and tender
• Using enough salt to bring all the flavors into focus and counteract any bitterness that might be lurking from the cocoa powder
• Taking the time to whip all the eggs together to add them a bit at a time makes for a very stable, thick, and billowy batter that bakes up with a lovely, tight, velvety crumb

Pan Size is Important

It turns out that mom’s pound cake recipe is nearly identical to all my pound cake variations. The basic formula, not including flavorings, leavenings, etc, is:

• 13 oz flour (about 3 cups)
• 12 oz unsalted butter (3 sticks)
• 20 oz granulated sugar (about 3 cups)
• 5 large eggs
• 10 oz by weight liquid (1 1/4 cups, usually of dairy of some sort)

If you don’t own a 12 cup Bundt pan, you can use other pans. This batter fits nicely in 2 9″ round pans.

If you are interested in a 12-cup Bundt though, this is my recommendation:

Check out my brown sugar cinnamon pound cake recipe. That recipe has the same proportions, and I baked some of the batter in a loaf pan, some in an 8″ round pan, and I also made 11 cupcakes.

Don’t be afraid to mix and match different size pans. If you need to check how many cups of batter a pan holds, Wilton has a great cake size chart that will help.

How To Make This Old-Fashioned Dark Chocolate Pound Cake

This cake is moist, sweet and delicious!

Pinner Kathy

Here’s a rundown of everything you’ll need so you can make your shopping list. You probably own a lot of ingredients already, especially if you do a lot of baking.

Ingredients (and Substitutions)

• unsalted butter: Carries the flavor and helps with browning, tenderness, and leavening (the creaming process). I prefer unsalted because I can better control the amount of salt in the recipe by simply adding my own measured amount
• salt: brings out the flavor. Counteracts any bitterness from the cocoa powder or instant coffee
• brown sugar: provides sweetness, tenderness, and the molasses in the brown sugar adds to the depth of flavor
• granulated sugar: provides the sweetness and assists with leavening (the creaming process). My mom originally made this cake with all white sugar, and you can too if you don’t have any brown sugar
• vanilla: rounds out the flavors. You could sub with chocolate extract or coffee extract if you’d rather
• eggs: helps with leavening, structure, tenderness. I use large eggs
• espresso powder: substitute instant coffee if you don’t have espresso powder. If your instant coffee is in big crystals (like mine) powder it using a mortar and pestle so it will easily incorporate with the batter
• all purpose flour: flour provides bulk and structure. If you prefer, you may use the same amount of cake flour rather than all-purpose. Your cake will be slightly more tender if you use cake flour. Mom always used all purpose, so either will work beautifully. Substitute cake flour for a finer texture
• cocoa powder: substitutes for part of the flour to bring dark chocolate flavor. Use “standard” un-alkalized cocoa powder, not Dutch process. I use regular, “grocery store cocoa powder.” When I have some, I use Ghirardelli.
• baking powder: emits gases to assist with leavening, once when it gets wet and again when it heats up in the oven (hence “double acting”)
• baking soda: neutralizes the acidic buttermilk and molasses so the batter has a balanced pH and bakes correctly. (Too acidic and your batter bakes up too quickly, too basic, and it may never actually set)
• buttermilk: acidic buttermilk tenderizes the crumb and provides liquid to make the batter light enough to rise well in the oven. You can use whole buttermilk, low-fat, or non-fat here. You may also choose to swap out up to half of the buttermilk for some plain yogurt or sour cream

Super easy. It tastes great ,moist. I added an extra yolk because not all my eggs were large. They were farm fresh and definitely cake worthy.

Pinner Lynette

The Mixing Method is Important

This cake is made using The Creaming Method, and as I mentioned above, I take the extra step of beating the eggs together and drizzling them in slowly rather than adding the eggs one at a time.

This way, you build the emulsion slowly so it stays nice and stable and yields the most melt-in-your-mouth cake ever. I promise!

How to Make It: Basic Rules for The Creaming Method

1. Beat butter until smooth and creamy.
2. Add the sugar and beat until light and fluffy, about 8 minutes.
3. Beat the eggs together in a bowl and drizzle them slowly into the batter over about five minutes or so. This results in the most stable emulsion possible.
4. Alternate adding the dry ingredients with the wet ingredients dry->wet->dry->wet->dry.
5. Pan and bake.

Videos

There is a video embedded in the recipe card below that shows in detail how to perform the creaming method.

The auto-play video for this post is of a whipping cream pound cake which uses the same method.

If you are interested in watching a real time video, I made this cake on Facebook live, and you can find that live chocolate pound cake video on Facebook.

Of course, watching it live is more fun, and you’ll hear a lot of references to things that have nothing to do with the cake, but if you have never made a pound cake before or you want a super deep dive into how I perform my modified creaming method, take a look at the video.

Fair warning, it’s almost an hour long, but you can skip through pretty quickly to watch the creaming action and see how billowy and gorgeous the batter is.

Here are some time stamps for you so you can find what you’re looking for:

• 1:50–ingredient list
• 6:00–beginning to scale out all the ingredients
• 12:39–getting butter, sugar, etc into mixer bowl for creaming
• 19:22–beginning to cream the butter and sugar
• 32:45–starting to add the eggs
• 45:33–alternating dry and wet ingredients
• 49:48–panning up the batter

The #1 Potential Pound Cake Problem

Sad Streaks and How to Avoid Them

A sad streak is a streak or ribbon of gummy, weird, “crumblessness” in the center or towards the bottom of your cake.

This can happen for a few reasons:

• Overbeating the eggs: even though I beat the eggs and add them gradually over a long period of time, I don’t beat them on high and only beat in 1 addition until I can’t see it anymore before adding the next. Overbeating can lead to the cake rising really high and then collapsing as it cools, causing the dreaded sad streak.
• Activating too much gluten: if you overbeat once you add the flour, you can activate too much gluten (especially if using all purpose flour rather than cake flour). This will make for a tough and potentially gummy cake. No thank you.
• Using too much leavening: in the same way that beating the eggs too long can cause your cake to rise high and then fall, adding too much leavening can lead to the same result. The cake will rise and then fall, leading to a sad streak.
• Letting your ingredients get too warm: If your butter gets too warm while mixing, you risk the batter being too delicate and collapsing. Keep all your ingredients very cool but not cold. Shoot for 62-65F if using my modified creaming method and no more than 68F if using the “regular” creaming method.

Pro Tip

TO REITERATE: Since the modified creaming method takes a bit longer, you want to make sure your butter is nice and firm and your eggs and dairy are still cool. Shoot for about 62-65F for all ingredients.

All your ingredients will warm up during mixing, so you want to keep them from getting too warm and ending up with a dreaded sad streak.

Another reason you can get a sad streak is by opening the oven door too soon–and leaving it open too long, especially if you bump or jostle the cake pan.

My rule of thumb is to leave the door closed until 10 minutes before the stated baking time. At that point, I can check the temperature and gauge how much longer it needs without worrying about the cake falling.

How to Make the Two-Tone Glaze

I think the glaze is so pretty! It’s also really easy to achieve.

The white layer is just my regular old glaze (and I never measure for glaze):

• powdered sugar
• a pinch of salt
• a splash of vanilla and
• just enough half and half to make a thick, barely pourable glaze

NOTE: For the new photos, I made the glaze with 2 oz cream cheese, 1 oz butter, pinch of salt, a touch of vanilla, 12 oz (3 cups) sifted powdered sugar and 2 1/2 tablespoons half and half.

The chocolate glaze is 1/2 cup chocolate chips, 1/2 cup heavy cream. In other words, a simple ganache.

Pipe it on with a pastry bag and a reusable #2 tip or just snip off a tiny corner of a zip top bag and use that.

How Does it Taste?

It’s a seriously delicious cake, y’all.

A little fudge-y and very chocolatey with a tight, meltingly fine crumb.

From Prior Experience, I can tell you that if you can stand to wait, this cake is even better a few days after baking. It just gets fudgier and fudgier.

Eat it with a tall glass of whole milk. Come back and tell me all about how it has Changed Your Life and made you Occasionally Selfish.

Freezing Instructions

This guy freezes really well for a good 3-4 months. Make sure it is well wrapped in both plastic wrap and then heavy-duty foil.

For ease of serving, I suggest slicing it before freezing. That way when you want a piece of cake, you can just take out what you need.

If you are planning to freeze the whole cake, wait until you thaw it out to glaze it. Then let the glaze set up for 2-3 hours before slicing and serving.

Questions?

Wondering if I have a lemon pound cake recipe? Why yes. Yes, I do!

If you have any questions about this recipe, any other recipe, or baking/cooking questions in general, don’t hesitate to get in touch.

Leave a comment here or email me. I promise I’ll get back to you as quickly as I can. Honest.

A Note About Measurements

NOTE: Most of my recipes are written by weight and not volume, even the liquids.

Even though I try to provide you with volume measurements as well, I encourage you to buy a kitchen scale for ease of measuring, accuracy, and consistency.

This is the scale I use, love, and recommend. If you’re unsure, please read my post about how to use a food scale.

Pin It!