Most Recent Update:
Candy is kind of the best. And chewy candy is the best of the best, because chewing is so satisfying. I think you will really enjoy this round up of chewy candy recipes.
Some of these candy recipes are my own while others are from around the Internet. All will satisfy your need to chew while you savor!
This post contains affiliate links. We are members of the Amazon Affiliate program. For any sale through our links, we earn a small commission. Your price is unaffected. For more information, please see our disclosure policy.
- 1 How to Make Chewy Candy
- 2 Other Ways to Make Candy Chewy
- 3 What Is the Best Temperature for Making Chewy Candy Recipes?
- 4 You May Need…
- 5 Chewy Candy Recipes
- 5.1 Old-Fashioned Chewy Butterscotch Candy
- 5.2 Pate de Fruits
- 5.3 Marshmallows
- 5.4 How to Make Old Fashioned Creamy Cocoa Fudge
- 5.5 Orange Cocoa Coffee Pulled Taffy
- 5.6 Coffee Maple Bacon Popcorn Treats
- 5.7 Caramel Sauce and Caramel Candy
- 5.8 ChefSteps
- 5.9 Cajeta Candy (Chewy Cinnamon Milk Candy)
- 5.10 Haribo Gold-Bears Gummy Candy
How to Make Chewy Candy
The most important thing to remember about making chewy candy recipes is the temperature you cook your sugar to has everything to do with the texture of your candy once it cools.
If you don’t cook it hot enough, you’ll end up with a soft candy or even a sauce. If you cook it too hot, you’ll end up with a crunchy candy.
And the worst for dental work: hard candy that turns super chewy and then sticks your teeth together. Yikes!
I have a stages of sugar chart that you should find helpful in figuring out how hot to cook your candy to get the texture you want.
Other Ways to Make Candy Chewy
Aside from the temperature of the sugar, you can also make chewy candies by adding either pectin or gelatin, like for gummy worms, marshmallows or other fruit chews.
The temperature is still important, but the pectin or gelatin adds body and mouthfeel.
What Is the Best Temperature for Making Chewy Candy Recipes?
For other candies that don’t contain pectin or gelatin, the “chewy range” is between about 245F and 270F.
Cook the sugar any hotter, and you’ll end up with super sticky candy that will glue your teeth together (like a Sugar Daddy or an Astro Pop, where it’s pretty hard to begin with but as you chew it gets really, really sticky.)
You May Need…
I’ve been talking about both gelatin and pectin. I don’t use any fancy brands or stuff only pastry chefs can find. These are the ones I recommend:
To be fair, to make traditional butterscotch, this would be a hard candy. But I love butterscotch flavor and wanted to make soft candy, so there you go. This is an old school recipe and appears to be the original formula for English butterscotch--very molasses forward and different from what Americans think of when they think of butterscotch.Continue Reading
Pate de fruit is pretty magical. Not gummy, but intensely fruity and somewhat chewy, it's a magical French candy rolled in sugar.Continue Reading
Homemade marshmallows, along with a video and a step by step guide. These are what I'll call "American marshmallows" since they don't contain egg whites.Get the Recipe
This is a very old-school fudge recipe. A reader sent in the ingredient list, and I helped with the procedure so her family could enjoy their grandma's fudge again.Continue Reading
These homemade Tootie Rolls walk the line between chewy and filling-pulling. But dang, they're delicious!Continue Reading
Made with homemade coffee marshmallows, bacon, and maple syrup, these "Krispie Treats" are like breakfast candy made with popcorn. You can also make these with store-bought mallows.Continue Reading
This post contains a live hangout where I made both caramel sauce and caramel candy. And I dipped some of the caramel in chocolate, so there's that. No written recipe, but you can click on the video to read the video description on YouTube. That's where you'll find the ingredient list. Enjoy!Continue Reading
This recipe uses sous vide technique and some specialized ingredients, but at the end of the day, you're making homemade Starburst, so that is pretty cool!Continue Reading
A chewy, cinnamon flavored dulce de leche. Yeah, I'm all over this one!Continue Reading
Homemade gummy bears! Great instructions and explanations in this post too.Continue Reading
And there you have it, friends. Ten amazing chewy candy recipes for you to make and enjoy at home, or to give as gifts.
Thank you for spending some time with me today.
Take care, and have a lovely day.