Homemade marshmallows are lovely and bear little resemblance to store-bought. They are a bit denser and more flavorful. These are ridiculously easy to make.
As written, the recipe makes chocolate marshmallows. There are endless ways to vary them, though. Coffee marshmallows are great, as are peppermint, orange, or almost any flavor you can think of.
The video in this post shows me making coffee marshmallows, but I make all sorts of flavors of mallows using the exact same process. Get creative with your candy!
And consider serving your marshmallows floating in some heavenly hot chocolate custard. (Serving Suggestion)
This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Your price is unaffected. For more information, please see our disclosure policy.
Types of Marshmallows
There are two major types of marshmallows. French marshmallows contain both gelatin and egg whites and the other is thickened solely with gelatin.
I prefer the gelatin version of homemade marshmallows because I don’t have to worry about any little bits of inadvertently scrambled egg white in my candy.
How to Make Homemade Marshmallows
Time needed: 8 hours and 30 minutes.
Homemade marshmallows are easier to make than you might think. It takes longer to wait for them to cure than it does to make them.
Note the 8 hours is inactive time.
- Prepare the Pan.
I like to spray a half sheet pan liberally with pan spray and then coat thickly with a mixture of corn syrup and powdered sugar. This makes the candy easy to get out of the pan once it has set up.
- Mix Gelatin, Water and Flavorings
In the bowl of your stand mixer, combine the gelatin, water, and any additional flavorings you’re adding. Allow the gelatin to bloom for about 5 minutes, and then turn the mixer, fitted with the whip attachment, on to low speed while you make the sugar syrup.
- Cook Sugar, Corn Syrup and Water.
Stir the sugar, corn syrup, and water together in a heavy-bottomed saucepan. Cook until the mixture reaches 244F on a candy thermometer or instant read thermometer.
- Pour the Cooked Sugar into the Gelatin Mixture.
Carefully stream the sugar syrup into the gelatin. Mix on low speed for a minute or so to completely dissolve the gelatin.
Slowly increase the speed of your mixer to high and whip until the candy triples in volume and gets very thick. You may hear your mixer’s motor labor some once it thickens.
- Pan Them Up
Use an oiled or pan-sprayed spatula to scrape the candy into the prepared pan. Spread it out as evenly as you can. You may have to add additional pan spray to keep it from sticking. Use a sieve to dust another liberal layer of corn starch and powdered sugar all over the top of the candy.
- Let the Candy Cure
Allow your newly minted homemade marshmallows to sit out, loosely covered, at room temperature for several hours or even overnight before cutting, tossing the cut candies in more powdered sugar and cornstarch, and storing in an air-tight container.
What Do I Need to Make Homemade Marshmallows?
You don’t need a lot of super fancy equipment to make mallows, but I highly recommend you get a stand mixer. The motor of even the best hand mixer cannot stand up to how thick homemade marshmallow gets.
If you’re a mallow fan, definitely get the best stand mixer you can afford and put it to work.
You’ll also need a half sheet pan (I like that size–it makes a ton of mallows that are perfect for sharing and gifting), an accurate thermometer, and something to cut them with–a greased pizza wheel is generally my choice, but you can also use greased kitchen shears.
Other Candy Recipes You Might Enjoy
If you’re a fan of homemade candy, I have a few recipes you may like. Let me know what’s your favorite!
- Butterscotch Hard Candy
- Chewy Butterscotch Candy
- Old Fashioned Divinity Candy
- Orange Cocoa Taffy (Homemade Tootsie Rolls)
- Butter Mints (No-Cook)
- 4 1/2 tablespoons powdered gelatin
- 1 cup plus 2 tablespoons cold water
- 1/2 teaspoon salt
- 1 teaspoon vanilla, (or flavoring of your choice)
- 3 cups sugar
- 2 cups corn syrup
- 2/3 cup cocoa powder, (for chocolate marshmallows)
- powdered sugar/corn starch, (1:1 ratio, more or less)
- In the bowl of your stand mixer, combine gelatin, cold water, salt and vanilla. Add the cocoa powder here, if using.
- I highly recommend using some peppermint extract along with the vanilla whether you're making plain or chocolate marshmallows. Stir well so there are no clumps of gelatin. Let it sit there while you do this:
- Spray a half-sheet pan with pan spray. (The pan spray is glue, in this case).
- Line the tray with plastic wrap, making sure it goes up the sides, too. If you have big air pockets under the wrap, poke them with a pin and press the wrap down onto the pan.
- Spray the pan again with pan spray. Put about 1 cup of powdered sugar/corn starch mixture in a strainer or sieve or sifter and sift a thick layer of sugar in the bottom of the pan.
- In a heavy saucepan over medium-high heat, bring sugar, corn syrup and a splash or two of water to a boil. Cover with a lid or plastic wrap, let boil for 2-3 minutes, then uncover.
- Cook sugar to 244 degrees, F.
- While sugar is coming to temperature, turn mixer, fitted with the whip attachment, on to medium-low.
- When sugar reaches 244F, remove from heat and carefully pour syrup down the inside of the mixing bowl.
- When it's all in, turn up speed to medium for a minute or so, then crank it to high and whip until the mixture is tripled in volume and starts to pull away from the sides of the bowl in threads.
- Surprise, surprise: the mixture will look like marshmallow cream.
- Remove bowl from mixer.
- Spray your biggest rubber spatula very well with pan spray on both sides.
- Use the lubed up spatula to coax the sticky marshmallow into the pan in a big pile. If it starts sticking, turn over the spatula, or spray with more pan spray.
- Spray the top of the big pile of marshmallow and the spatula with more pan spray (all hail the pan spray), and smooth out the marshmallow as evenly as you can. It should reach the top of the half-sheet pan.
- Sift a generous amount of powdered sugar/corn starch over the top (you don't want any shiny marshmallow showing through) and let sit, uncovered, at room temperature to set up. This could take several hours.
- Once set, cut with a greased cutter into fun shapes, or use a greased knife or scissors. Toss cut mallows in more of the powdered sugar mixture to keep the sides from drying out.
This recipe makes one sheet pan or two half-sheets. Feel free to cut the recipe in half to make one 1/2 sheet.
Alternately, but much more messily, you could scoop the unwieldy marshmallow goo out of the mixer and into a large pastry bag. Use a well-greased spatula to do this. Once in the bag, you can pipe little kisses of marshmallow. If it has whipped enough, it will stand up in little peaks. Sift 10x mixture over the kisses until set up.
Brush off excess sugar, dip in tempered chocolate (or coating chocolate) or not. Throw them in your hot chocolate. Use your torch to brulee them for s'mores. Give them as presents. Eat them in the bathtub.