Soft Chocolate Cookies

These soft chocolate cookies are rich and buttery. Stuffed with dried tart cherries, sweet vanilla baking chips, and mellow toasted pecans, the mix of textures and flavors makes them hard to stop eating.

Read on for the how-tos and some ways to vary the recipe to suit your taste. If it’s chocolate cookie recipes that really make your heart go pitter-patter, you will probably also enjoy my chocolate peppermint crinkle cookies or my crispy chocolate cookies.

For ease of browsing, you can find all my cookie and bar recipes in one place. Thank you so much for being here.

Soft Chocolate Cookies, At a Glance

✅Skill Level: Beginner
✅Skills: The Creaming Method
✅Type: Soft Cookies
✅Number of Ingredients: 10 for the dough, 3 mix-ins, optional
✅Prep Time: 15-20 minutes
✅Cook Time: 25 minutes
✅Yield: 48 with mixins and about 36 plain

Jump Straight to the Recipe

Why You Need to Make These Chocolate Cookies

What’s to love:

• Deep chocolate flavor underscored with espresso powder
• They will start out a little crisp but will soften into lovely soft chocolate cookies after a few hours. And even though they’re soft, they don’t crumble and make a huge mess
• Makes 4 dozen with mix-ins and around 2 1/2-3 dozen if baking plain
• Easy to make with a stand mixer or a hand mixer

Anything that might trip me up?

Using a kitchen scale will give you the best results that are most like the ones I got. If you are scooping/sweeping or packing your cups with flour, your results could differ a lot from the written recipe.

What Makes These Chocolate Cookies Thick and Soft?

Using all brown sugar makes for a softer cookie. Brown sugar has molasses in it, which makes the cookies moister to begin with. Combine that with sugar’s hygroscopic properties (it draws water to it from the atmosphere), and that alone can help you have soft cookies.

Baking powder adds a little lift and puff, allowing the cookies to bake up a bit more on the cakey rather than crunchy side.

Eggs provide structure, allowing for a thicker cookie, and the yolks promote tenderness since they are mostly made up of fat and emulsifiers.

Last, baking at 350, which is moderate for cakes but maybe a little on the high side for small cookies, allows the cookies to set up more quickly before they can spread and thin out too much. This results in a thicker, softer cookie.

Note: The best way to describe the texture of these cookies is to compare them to Lofthouse-style iced sugar cookies. Without the icing. And very chocolatey. The edges will be crispy to begin with, and then the whole cookie softens into the muffled crumble of a great soft but not cakey cookie.

The Case For, and Against, Mix-ins

Here are the chocolate cookies, plain, sans mix-ins.

You’ll get no complaint from me.

Either way works!

Pro Mix-Ins:

• You can vary the flavor and add textural interest
• Cookies will spread less and be thicker since many mix-ins are denser than the dough and heat more slowly
• When it comes to mix-ins, the sky is the limit

Con Mix-Ins:

• If you are looking for unrelieved chocolatey goodness, sometimes a simple chocolate cookie is the way to go
• The cookies will spread more without mix-ins.

Credit Where Credit Is Due

I started my experimenting with this recipe from Sweetest Menu.

Testing has to start somewhere, and I like to start with a solid, proven recipe and then tweak it until I get the results I want.

How To Make

These are straightforward cookies that are made with the creaming method.

In this section, I’ll go over all the ingredients as well as substitutions where applicable. You’ll also get a step-by-step rundown of making the dough as well as my recommendations for equipment and ways to vary the flavor of these cookies to suit your taste.

If you are ready to bake, please feel free to jump straight to the recipe.

Ingredients and Substitutions

Here’s what you’ll need to make soft chocolate cookies:

• flour: All-purpose works great here. Flour adds bulk and structure to the cookies
• cocoa powder: I use a “regular” American-style cocoa powder. If you use Dutch process, you can leave out the baking soda
• baking soda: neutralizes the acidic ingredients (cocoa powder and instant coffee)
• baking powder: Adds a touch of leavening to give the cookies a bit of puff and keep them soft
• butter: at cool room temperature. I use unsalted
• brown sugar: Provides sweetness, a little extra depth from the molasses, as well as softness. Cookies sweetened with brown sugar spread less and absorb more liquid, keeping the cookies soft
• instant coffee: Just enough to underscore the chocolate flavor. The cookies do not taste at all like coffee. Use instant coffee or espresso powder. Either will work
• vanilla extract: Rounds out the flavors and provides some nice floral notes
• salt: Snaps all the flavors into focus. Please don’t leave out the salt. I call for one teaspoon, plus an optional few flakes of sea salt on top. You can forgo the flaky salt, but the chocolate really needs the salt in the recipe
• eggs: Provide structure, a touch of “lift” or leavening, and extra moisture. The eggs help to keep these cookies softer
• pecans: I toast pecan halves in the toaster oven and then chop them fairly fine. Leave them out or substitute any other toasted nut: hazelnuts, cashews, or walnuts would be lovely
• white baking chips: You can also use a white chocolate bar and chop into “chip-sized” pieces. Substitute dark or milk chocolate chips
• dried tart cherries: I love the pops of sweet-tart dried cherries. Feel free to leave them out or substitute Craisins, raisins, or chopped, dried apricot

Procedure

These cookies are very straightforward to make.

I divide the ingredients into 4 parts:

• ingredients to be creamed together first: butter, brown sugar, salt, espresso powder, and vanilla
• eggs that get beaten in one at a time after creaming
• dry, which I whisk together first before adding to the bowl: flour, cocoa powder, baking powder, and baking soda
• then the chopped pecans, white chips, and dried cherries which all get mixed in at the end (an optional step, obviously, if you are making plain cookies)

Visual How-To

Here are a couple of collage images to show you how to make the dough.

1. Butter, brown sugar, salt, vanilla, and espresso powder go in a bowl, or the bowl of your stand mixer.
2. Cream until smooth and uniform.
3. Add the eggs, one at a time, beating well to make sure each is incorporated before adding the next. Scrape the bowl as necessary.
4. Add the dry ingredients (flour, baking powder, baking soda, and cocoa powder), all at once, and mix until mostly mixed.

1. The dough is almost mixed–see there is still some loose flour?
2. Dump in the mixins (if using) all at once and mix until evenly distributed.
3. Portion the dough in 1 oz (2 Tablespoon) portions. I sprinkled a few flakes of sea salt on top of each one.
4. The cookies, fresh out of the oven and cooling on a rack. Baking takes between 13-17 minutes, depending on how crisp you’d like the edges to be.

NOTE the cookies do soften after a few hours.

Equipment You May Need

You can make these cookies using a stand mixer or a hand mixer. I tested it both ways, and both work well.

I like to bake on half-sheet pans, because they are very versatile. I also use them as roasting pans, for making jelly rolls, for cooking vegetables, etc.

If you don’t weigh your cookies, use a 2-Tablespoon cookie scoop so all your cookies come out a uniform size.

You may also want to check with my post about tools for serious bakers to see if there are any other equipment necessities you can pick up.

Variations

These cookies are very easy to vary. You can add spices to the dough, switch up flavorings, and of course swap out mix-ins as well. Just stick to roughly 3 cups total mix-ins, and you’ll be fine.

• Minty Chocolate Cookies: Add 3-4 drops of peppermint oil to the dough. Use crushed candy canes and peppermint bark as the mix-ins
• Cherry Chocolate Cookies: Substitute chopped red and green glace cherries for the mix-ins called for in the recipe
• Chocolate Cashew Cookies: Add the zest of one orange to the dough and substitute chopped toasted cashews for the mix-ins called for in the recipe
• Triple Chocolate Chocolate Chip Cookies: Swap out a mixture of dark, milk, and white chocolate chips for the mix-ins called for

For another take on a soft chocolate cookies that adds the gooey factor, try this Softbatch Cream Cheese Chocolate Cookies. Gooey with cream cheese and chocolate chips, these are a chocolate-lover’s dream cookie.

Tips for Success

No need to refrigerate this dough, but it is pretty sticky. A 30-minute rest in the fridge does make it easier to handle.

For more uniform soft cookies, roll the dough into balls between your hands before baking.

Note that the cookies will spread more without mix-ins. With mix-ins, you’ll end up with smaller, thicker cookies. Either way, your cookies will be nice and soft, especially after the first day.

Chocolate Cookies Q & A

Serving Suggestions

These little guys would be a wonderful addition to a cookie tray.

I always like a mix of colors, shapes, and sizes, so pair them with angel slices, some brown butter chocolate chip cookies, and throw in a few pieces of candy: penuche or peanut butter fudge would be a great choice.

And if you just want to enjoy chocolate cookies by themselves, pair them with a tall glass of milk, maybe some orange hot chocolate, or a homemade adult peppermint mocha latte.

Questions?

If you have any questions about this post or recipe, I am happy to help.

Simply leave a comment here and I will get back to you soon. I also invite you to ask question in my Facebook group, Fearless Kitchen Fun.

If your question is more pressing, please feel free to email me. I should be back in touch ASAP, as long as I’m not asleep.

A Note About Measurements

My recipes are almost all written by weight, including liquids, unless otherwise specified.

For accuracy and consistency of results, I encourage you to buy–and use–a kitchen scale.

I promise that baking and cleanup will be so much quicker and easier.

This is the scale that I recommend for home use. I have owned and used one for years.

Love These Chocolate Cookies? Please Rate and/or Review

Thanks for spending some time with me today.

I really hope you love these soft chocolate cookies, whether or not you add the mix-ins.

Take care, y’all.