Cubano Pizza Recipe| Cuban Sandwich Grandma Pizza

What Is the Sauce?

Friends, it is as simple as this: mustard.

I used Brownwood Farms’ Famous Kream Mustard which, while a perfect balance of sweet and spicy by itself was a touch sweet to offset the fattiness of the cheeses and meats I used.

To make sure there was enough sharpness from the mustard in the finished pie, I zigzagged some yellow mustard over the Famous Kream Mustard and also over the finished pizza.

If you are not as in love with mustard as I am, you can skip this step if you’d like.

I made a second pizza using plain yellow mustard, and that was sharp enough to balance the Unctuousness of the toppings.

You can also mix some dill pickle juice with the mustard to make the Cubano pizza sauce, especially if you are a fan of pickles and want that flavor in every single bite.

If you don’t like the flavor of mustard without the sharp bite, do consider giving the Famous Kream Mustard a try. It’s one of the only mustards I’ve ever wanted to just eat right off a spoon.

NOTE: Once I spread the mustard on the grandma pizza dough, I dusted the whole crust with cumin and oregano to underscore the Cuban flavor profile.

How Do You Fix the Roast Pork?

I actually experimented two ways, and I’ll them up and link to those posts when they’re up.

I took a pork shoulder, deboned it (or you can buy a boneless pork shoulder), and then cut it in half.

I marinated both halves in Roy Choi’s mojo marinade that he developed for Jon Favreau’s 2014 movie, Chef.

• For one half, I wiped off the majority of the marinade and roasted it in the oven for about 3 hours.
• For the other half, I put it and all its marinade (plus additional water) in my Instant Pot and let it cook on high pressure for 45 minutes.

After taste testing both pork shoulders, we decided that using the Instant Pot mojo pork was the way to go.

The oven-roasted pork was really succulent with great pork flavor, but it didn’t keep a lot of that fresh citrus/cilantro/mint flavor of the marinade. It sliced beautifully but wasn’t cooked long enough to shred. Ideal for actual Cuban sandwiches.

Since we wanted shreds of pork and not slices (for ease of both cutting the pizza and eating it), we went with the shreddable, Instant Pot mojo pork.

We also went with the shreds because we loved the fresh citrus flavor of the pork marinade and wanted it to carry through to the pizza.

It is totally your call. You can use small slices of oven-roast pork or shreds of Instant Pot pork. It’s completely dependent upon what flavor you are looking for in your Ultimate Cubano Pizza!

Tips for Making It Delicious

• Use the best crust possible. For me, that generally means homemade, but you can also use fresh dough you buy from a local pizza place or from the deli section at the grocery store
• Don’t overload the pizza: you want to make sure that you get most of the ingredients in every bite and all of them on every slice, but if you completely blanket the dough in a ton of toppings, it will take forever to bake.
• It’s your pizza: If your favorite part of a Cuban sandwich is the mustard, make sure you use a very sharp mustard. If your favorite part is the pickles, use more pickles. It’s your pizza, so use the most of whatever you want the predominant flavor to be.
• Bake the pizza on the lowest shelf of your oven, because that’s where the heat comes from. The intense heat towards the bottom of your oven will help brown the crust.
• Watch your oven temperature. If you make a grandma pizza like I did, bake at a lower temperature to make sure it cooks through. If using a thin crust (even if you just end up stretching the grandma dough out thin) bake at the highest temperature your oven will reach.

Why This Pizza Works

There is a reason a Cuban sandwich works so well. It’s the interplay of different flavors and textures: fatty pork, salty ham, mellow, nutty Swiss cheese, the briny pickles and of course the sharp mustard all on soft Cuban bread that gets crispy on the outside when pressed. It’s pretty much a perfect sandwich.

I tried hard to bring the same balance to my Cuban-style pizza as I could.

• light grandma pizza dough with a feathery crumb that gets crisp on the outsides as it bakes in the oven/fries in the olive oil in the pan
• two different mustard choices: a sweet-hot or a sharp yellow. Both good choices and completely dependent on how you want your finished pizza to taste.
• mellow, nutty, thick-sliced Swiss cheese
• dill pickle chips–you could also use sweet pickles. Again, it is your call. I think if you go with sweet pickles, you may really like the sweet-hot flavor profile of the Brownwood Farms Famous Kream Mustard.
• Instant Pot mojo pulled pork–I chose the IP pork because I really liked the fresh citrus and herb flavor the marinade brings. You can use your favorite roast pork or pulled pork, or stick with the famous Roy Choi marinade.
• Deli ham. I bought Boar’s Head, but you can use your favorite sandwich ham here.
• Mozzarella cheese, because for me, pizza needs a bit of stretchy cheese.
• I accented the Cuban flavor profile in every bite by dusting the pizza with cumin and oregano, both on top of the sauce and once more right before serving.

Step by Step Instructions

Whether you’re using the grandma pizza dough that I used (linked both in the introduction and in the recipe itself) or you’re using some other pizza dough, you’ll want to prepare your pan.

For grandma pizza, this means to line a half sheet pan with parchment and then pour on about 1/4 cup of olive oil. Spread your dough out so it fills the pan. For directions on how to do this, see my Grandma pizza dough recipe, linked in the recipe.

From there, it’s an assembly process. 

Start with a base of your sauce (straight up mustard or a mixture of mustard and pickle juice. You could also consider mixing mustard with some of your pork marinade if you want to carry the citrus flavor.

After you add the sauce, sprinkle 2 Tablespoons minced garlic over the top. This is technically optional, but if you love garlic, it is NOT optional. 

NOTE: Please bring any marinade you used for the pork to a boil for food safety purposes. Especially if you want to taste before you bake your pie!

You will only need 7-8 slices of Swiss cheese. We placed them so there will be Swiss cheese on every piece of pizza though not necessarily in every bite.

Next up? Ham. We tore slices of ham in half and placed them in little “piles” on top of and around the cheese. As with the cheese, you will only need 7-8 slices of ham.

It’s time for the pork. Whether you use slices of roast pork or you use pulled pork, make sure to space them evenly over the pie.

Altogether, we used about 1 cup of pulled pork.

Next up? Pickles! We like dill chips, but feel free to use sweet “bread & butter” pickles instead. NOTE: drain the pickles on a paper towel or with a lint-free kitchen towel to get excess brine off of them. We don’t want a soggy pizza.

Last up, mozzarella. We used 8 oz, grated.

For best melty goodness, buy mozzarella in a block and grate it yourself with a box grater. Pre-shredded contains starches or other additives to keep it from sticking together and make it less than ideal for melting. If pre-shredded is all you have, though, go for it. Your Cuban Pizza will still be Ever So Good!

Please Take a Moment to Admire the Crust

I’m serious, you guys. Grandma pizza is the best. For real. Just look at that crust and that open, airy crumb!

If you love a thick crust pizza but don’t like them if they’re too heavy, you will want to make this dough and then use it for everything!

If that picture sets your heart fluttering, you may also want to give my Lasagna Pizza a whirl. It’s a grandma pizza too. I cannot get enough!

Reader Rave

Pinner Alexis made her own Cubano pizza the other day. Her review was very short and to the point. Hopefully her photo is worth 1000 words!

So good.

Pinner Alexis

I hope you’re inspired to pile all your favorite Cuban sammich fixin’s onto a mustard-slathered grandma crust, too.

Take it from me and Alexis. It is So Good!

If you have any questions about this or any other recipe or post on the site, there are a few ways to get in touch.

You can leave a comment on the post, and I’ll be back in touch within 24 hours.

If your question is more pressing, don’t hesitate to email me, and I should be back in touch within 4 hours (unless I’m asleep) or often much more quickly than that.

A Note About Measurements

This is the kitchen scale that I recommend for home cooks and bakers. Using a scale will help you be more accurate and consistent in your measurements.

It is lightweight, easy to store, accurate, and very easy to use.

I hope you’ve learned something from this post or that you’ve decided to make the recipe.

It would really help me and other readers out if you’d rate the recipe using the star ratings in the recipe card.

It’s also very helpful to me and to other readers if you leave a comment and/or a recipe review.

Thank you so much for being here and for helping others find my recipes by sharing on your social platforms!

And there you have it. A completely delicious Cubano pizza made with mojo marinated pulled pork. Stay tuned for that recipe, friends!

Thanks for spending some time with me today. Take care, and have a lovely day.