Whipped Shortbread Cookies

Why Do Some Recipes Have Cornstarch?

Cornstarch can be a secret ingredient. It adds bulk to dough or batter without adding additional protein, so it can make cakes and cookies more tender.

And I love Instant Clear Jel, which is modified cornstarch, for making magical stabilized whipped cream.

I guess at some point, folks decided it could do the same for whipped shortbread cookies.

I guess that could be true if all you have on hand is bread flour, but I’m here to tell you that it is not necessary to use cornstarch in your whipped shortbread recipe, friends.

To ensure my recipe wouldn’t require any additional ingredients other than salted butter, sugar, and flour, I used cake flour since it’s naturally lower in protein, and I grabbed my bag of confectioner’s sugar, because that bakes up very delicately as well.

The third thing I did was to alter the mixing method from the standard creaming method used for most cookies, including standard shortbread, and went with a modified reverse creaming method that I use to make my sour cream cinnamon coffee cake.

But since there are only 3 ingredients and no eggs or liquid, this is what that modification looks like here:

• Put all ingredients in the bowl of your mixer.
• Turn it on and beat until fluffy.
• The End.

Why You Need to Make These Whipped Shortbread Cookies

The main reason to make this recipe is that it is 100% delicious.

I have added a bit of nutmeg to the batter, and nutmeg and butter go together beautifully.

I should note it wasn’t my idea. A reader is trying to replicate her grandmother’s recipe, and grandma always used nutmeg.

Smart lady.

Anyway, for anyone who has a corn allergy, these will work great for you. Just make sure your powdered sugar doesn’t have cornstarch in it.

Also, these cookies are ridiculously easy to make. I mean, put everything in the mixing bowl and mix until the dough looks like buttercream. Done.

I personally like the piped cookies because the edges are so delicate.

Many people grew up with the kind with a fork impression in them, and those are just as tasty.

And as far as decor, you can make these for any occasion, including “hey, it’s teatime.”

Use different sprinkles and enjoy them for any holiday: Christmas, Easter, Valentine’s Day, etc.

How To Make

As I’ve said, these cookies are very easy to make.

If you’ve not made these before, I have a few pointers for you, too.

Ingredients and Substitutions

With an ingredient list so short and such pure flavors, you will want to use the best quality ingredients you can find.

• butter: This is not the time for store-brand butter. Use the best quality salted butter you can find. I used Kerry Gold. Its rich, yellow color comes from the rich milk of grass-fed cows, and the butter flavor is very pronounced. Do NOT substitute unsalted butter without adding in some additional salt. A very healthy 1/4 teaspoon of fine salt should do. If you don’t use salted butter or add salt, your cookies will taste very flat and you’ll wonder what the fuss is all about.
• powdered sugar: I use any brand that says “cane sugar” on it. If the bag doesn’t say that, it could be made from beets, which isn’t a bad thing in and of itself. It does tend to get “wetter” than cane sugar, though.
• cake flour: Use bleached cake flour such as Swans Down. Aside from being made with low-protein wheat, the bleaching further softens the proteins and limits gluten production. It can usually be found near the cake mixes in the grocery store. If you cannot find bleached cake flour, try a low-protein all-purpose flour such as White Lily.
• nutmeg: Freshly grated nutmeg will have a much more pungent aroma and intense flavor than ground.

Procedure

This is easy, y’all. Ready?

1. Place all the ingredients in the bowl of your stand mixer fitted with the paddle attachment.
2. Mix on medium-low speed until there is no loose flour or sugar in the bowl.
3. Increase speed to medium-to-medium-high, and beat, scraping the bowl as necessary, until the mixture is light and fluffy like frosting.

Once you have made your dough, you have choices about how to make your cookies:

• Simply drop tablespoon-sized portions onto a parchment-lined pan and call it a day. Or add sprinkles and/or a half glace cherry
• Load into a piping bag fitted with a star attachment and pipe in rosettes wreaths, hearts, or whatever you desire. TIP: If making for a special occasion and you want color to be a theme, consider adding a little food coloring to your dough when you start mixing.
• Load into a cookie press and press cookies directly onto parchment
• Refrigerate the dough for about 45 minutes and then portion into tablespoon-sized portions (about 1/2 ounce each) and then quickly roll each into a ball. Press the back of a fork into each ball and then sprinkle with desired sprinkles. NOTE: You must refrigerate your dough to ensure it is firm enough to roll into balls. Otherwise, it’s like trying to roll whipped lotion into balls. Impossible.

Regardless of how you shape them, bake them in a 300F oven for 19 minutes. I know that’s a very specific time, but it is what it is. Enough time for the cookies to set without browning.

Your oven may run a little cooler or hotter than mine, so check them starting at about 15 minutes.

Visual How-To

This collage shows what the dough/whipped batter looks like every step of the way:

1. All four ingredients–cake flour, soft salted butter, powdered sugar, and nutmeg–go in the mixer bowl.
2. Start on low speed until the mixture is crumbly.
3. Continue on medium-low speed until the dough just comes together with no loose flour or sugar in the bottom of the bowl.
4. Increase speed to medium and whip for a few minutes, scraping the bowl as necessary.
5. Turn the speed up to medium-high and continue whipping for a couple of minutes more until the dough is light and airy and looks like buttercream.
6. The finished whipped dough.

Equipment You May Need

While I’m sure grandma made these by hand with a big old wooden spoon, I am not grandma.

I recommend using a stand mixer to make these cookies. A hand mixer might work, but it would take a very long time to beat it until the dough has the consistency of frosting.

You’ll also want to bake on a sturdy half-sheet pan or two.

Cheaper cookie sheets will warp when they get hot, and then your cookies will not have flat bottoms.

To make pressed cookies, you’ll need a cookie press. I recommend this one by OXO.

Variations

These are classic cookies, and they don’t really need much done to them.

You can certainly alter the flavor a bit by omitting the nutmeg and/or adding 1/2-1 teaspoon of vanilla.

Here are some decorating ideas so you can at least switch up the visual appeal:

• Roll dough balls in sugar before pressing the back of a fork into them.
• Use different sprinkles or colored sugars to vary the look.
• Make an indentation in the centers of either dough balls or piped cookies and fill with a teaspoon of jam before baking.
• Press a candy-coated chocolate into the centers immediately after baking. Don’t press too hard or you’ll end up with a candy shoved all the way through–remember these are delicate cookies. Just press hard enough to recess the candy by about 1/8 inch or so
• Drizzle the cooled cookies with some pastel candy melts (these would be cute for Easter or a baby shower) or chocolate (for any time!)

Tips for Success

You may be tempted to use the whisk attachment, but the paddle does a much better job of the initial creaming. It also works really well for incorporating air, so stick with the paddle attachment for making whipped shortbread.

These cookies are extremely fragile when hot, so allow them to cool for 3-5 minutes on the parchment-lined cookie sheet before carefully moving them to a cooling rack using an offset spatula. Don’t try to pick them us as you would a “regular” cookie. This will just make you sad.

I tested these cookies with and without refrigeration after piping, and I found very little difference. So, once shaped, go ahead and pop them in the oven. There should be very little spread although the piped cookies will “soften” a bit.

Whipped Shortbread Cookies Q & A

A Word About the Amount of Sugar

I tested these cookies with two amounts of powdered sugar: 2.5 oz and 3 ounces.

The ones with more sugar were much more fragile and spread a bit more than the cookies with a lesser amount of sugar.

If you want your cookies on the sweeter side, go ahead and use 3 ounces, and consider putting the formed cookies in the freezer for about 30 minutes before baking to limit the spread.

The cookies with more sugar will also take about 4 extra minutes to bake through, so set your timer for 23 minutes, give or take, depending on your oven.

Once baked, allow them to sit on the baking pan undisturbed for a good 5 minutes before using an offset spatula to carefully move them, one at a time, to a cooling rack to cool completely.

Serving Suggestions

Since whipped shortbread is a classic Christmas cookie, consider assembling cookie trays for holiday dessert tables or gifts.

Along with these guys, maybe add some angel slices, some crispy cocoa cookies, chocolate peppermint crinkle cookies, and some old-fashioned fudge.

These would be delicious served with coffee, a nice chai, hot chocolate, or a decadent, warm Tom & Jerry in front of the Christmas tree.

A Note About Measurements

NOTE: Most of my recipes are written by weight and not volume, even the liquids.

Even though I try to provide you with volume measurements as well, I encourage you to buy a kitchen scale for ease of measuring, accuracy, and consistency.

This is the scale I use, love, and recommend. If you’re unsure, please read my post about how to use a food scale.

Questions

If you have questions about this post or recipe, don’t hesitate to get in touch. You can leave a comment on the post and I will get back to you within about 24 hours.

If your question is more urgent, please shoot me an email, and I will respond within 4 hours, unless I’m asleep.

Thanks for spending some time with me today.

I’m excited for y’all to try these whipped shortbread cookies!

Take care, and have a lovely day.