Hot Chocolate Custard with Coffee Marshmallows| Progressive Eats

Hot Chocolate Custard 7Welcome to this month's Progressive Eats meal, and what a doozy! New permanent member Susan from The Wimpy Vegetarian has chosen a fantastic theme: Weekend Ski Party. Nice, right? It conjures up images of swooshing down the slopes all day and then filling up on warming, cheesy, gooey, comfort food with a hot toddy to warm you from top to toe.

If you're unfamiliar with the concept, a progressive dinner involves going from house to house, enjoying a different course at each location. With Progressive Eats, a theme is chosen each month, members share recipes suitable for a delicious meal or party, and you can hop from blog to blog to check them out. This month, I picture us all shooshing from one stop to the next. Won't you join us?

We have a core group of 12 bloggers, but we will always need substitutes and if there is enough interest would consider additional groups. To see our upcoming themes and how you can participate, please check out the schedule at Creative Culinary or contact Barb for more information.

Weekend Ski Party...?

Hot Chocolate Custard 6I have been skiing exactly 1 1/2 times in my life. The first time was with our youth group from church. We went to Sugar Mountain, NC. Most of the kids at our church had ski clothes. Some even had their own boots and their own skis. We had never been skiing, so I had nothing. The helpful information the church sent home suggested using Scotch Guard on a pair of jeans and having thermal underwear as well if we didn't own ski clothes. So that's what we did.

SSSShhhhhhhhhhhhsssssshhhhhhhhhhhh.....shhhhhhhhhsssssshhhhhhhhhhhhhhh The sound of the Scotch Guard as my mother waved it back and forth over a forlorn pair of jeans. The jeans darkening with what we thought was a shellac-like imperviousness to ice and snow. Cotton thermals from Sears? Check. And we were off.

Friends, let me tell you. I have never spent so much time on my ass as I did during that ski weekend. Sliding down hills on my posterior seemed so much more safe than descending strapped to two tongue depressors. Bunny slope? Kiddie slope? Mostly flat areas? My ass came to know them well.

And the snow, compacted by jeans-clad bottom, laughed at my Scotch Guard. Mocked it. Soaked into the knees of my jeans and of course the seat, leaving dark blue patches on my long johns. Long Jennis? I kept those thermal underwear for years, and those blue patches, while lightening with wash after wash, still mocked me and my pitiful attempts at skiing.

Hot Chocolate Custard 3The lodge was home base. It was where I could safely wander around in normal people shoes without being looked at funny. Awkward poles and wet clothes put away, warm and cozy in sweats, most of the people there who were not in my group had no idea I had spent humiliating hours out on the slopes on my ass. I could pretend to be someone who had returned from a supremely satisfying day of swooshing about without the need to snowplow. For all anyone knew, I was someone who could ski!

And what about that extra 1/2 time of skiing? That too was with our youth group. I put wanting desperately to fit in with this church group ahead of sure humiliation and went back the next year. Although year two was humiliating in a different way: I didn't ski at all. The cost of the weekend trip without lift tickets and ski rental was $13, so I went the cheap route. And the route where my ass wouldn't be wet and numb all weekend long.

Since my real experiences with skiing were less than idyllic, I have created a ski lodge in my mind. A lodge where skiing is totally secondary to chatting by a fire, an afterthought to a long, lingering, multi-course breakfast. In my lodge, shaggy area rugs are scattered around. There are roaring fires in stone fireplaces (one of which is arched), plenty of board games to choose from, tons of guilty pleasure books lining the bookshelves and a hot beverage never more than an arms length away.

Hot Chocolate Custard

Hot Chocolate Custard 4Some beverages are made to be guzzled down to quench thirst. Other beverages are meant to be sipped and savored. Guess which kind of beverage this is?

This hot chocolate custard is rich enough to serve as dessert. The mini coffee marshmallows make a perfect, cute but sophisticated garnish as they slowly melt into the chocolate.

A few years ago, I mentioned that I add an egg yolk to my hot chocolate, and lots of folks were appalled. But think of it as a hot chocolate eggnog and that might help. The yolk adds just a bit more richness, a little more body to the drink, allowing it to straddle the line between drink and dessert. The marshmallows push it over that line squarely into the dessert category.

Serve this is small portions. If you'd like to lighten it up a bit so it's more a beverage than a dessert, by all means leave out the yolk and make it with all milk. Do try it in its original form at least once though. It is deeply satisfying and delicious. And it's also the house beverage of my imaginary ski lodge.

5.0 from 2 reviews
Hot Chocolate Custard
Cook time: 
Total time: 
Serves: 6-8
Like tea or coffee, chocolate needs time to steep. The cocoa solids suspended in the fats in the chocolate need time to hydrate. That's why making this hot chocolate is a two-step process. You can make and refrigerate the base the day before if you'd like.
What You Need
For the Base
  • 4 oz good-to-excellent quality dark chocolate (I usedGhirardelli 60%)
  • 12 oz whole milk
  • 4 oz half and half
To Finish
  • 2 oz whole milk
  • 1-2 Tablespoons sugar or brown sugar (to taste, and completely optional, especially if you're garnishing with marshmallows)
  • 1 egg yolk
  • heavy pinch of non-iodized salt (kosher, sea salt, etc)
  • All of chocolate base
  • ¼ teaspoon pure vanilla extract or vanilla paste
What To Do
For the Base
  1. Finely chop or grate the chocolate. Set aside.
  2. Bring the milk and half and half to a simmer over medium heat, stirring occasionally.
  3. Once the milk is hot, stir while slowly adding the chocolate a bit at a time. Stir until smooth.
  4. Bring the mixture to a very slow boil/high simmer and cook for 2-3 minutes, stirring constantly. This just concentrates the mixture and thickens it up a bit. This is an optional step, but I highly recommend it.
  5. Let this base sit for at least an hour or cool it down and refrigerate it overnight.
To Finish
  1. In a small bowl, whisk together the whole milk and egg yolk.
  2. Whisk this mixture into the chocolate base aong with the salt and, whisking constantly, heat the chocolate to 165F.
  3. Taste and add the sugar (if using). Strain the mixture into a pitcher. It should be very frothy and have a nice head on it. If not, whisk and whisk until it does. A milk frother is inexpensive and works well for this.
  4. Pour into demitasse or espresso cups
  5. , garnish with coffee marshmallows (or the garnish of your choice) and indulge.

Coffee Marshmallows

Hot Chocolate Custard 2If you've never made marshmallows before, coffee or otherwise, I have made you a helpful video. Take a look and then read on for the recipe for these coffee mallows.




5.0 from 2 reviews
Coffee Marshmallows
This recipe makes one ½ sheet pan (12"x18") of 1" thick marshmallow or one 9"x13" pan of 1½"-2" thick marshmallow. Feel free to make a half recipe if you'd like.

I made these to may taste. You may like more or less coffee flavor than I do. You could certainly use cold coffee in place of the water if you'd like. If you use water, or even if you start with coffee, start with less instant coffee and extract, taste once the mixture has cooled down enough and then add more if you want a stronger flavor.
What You Need
  • 4½ Tablespoons powdered gelatin (4 Tablespoons plus 1½ teaspoons)
  • 9 oz (1 cup plus 2 Tablespoons) cold water
  • ¼ teaspoon kosher salt
  • 2½ Tablespoons instant coffee (I used Medaglia D'Oro)
  • 1 teaspoon coffee extract (optional, but I like the extra top notes. Your call)
  • 21 oz (3 cups) granulated sugar
  • 2 cups light corn syrup (not sure of the weight on this one)
  • A mixture of half powdered sugar/half corn starch for dusting both the pan and the marshmallow
  • Optional: real chocolate sprinkles
  • *or* melted and tempered chocolate *or* melted good quality coating chocolate
What To Do
To Prepare the Pan
  1. Spray your pan (rimmed cookie sheet/jelly roll pan/1/2 sheet pan/9"x13" Pyrex) with pan spray. This is what will hold your plastic wrap in place.
  2. Press a sheet of plastic wrap down onto the pan making sure it sticks along the bottom and up the sides. Use two overlapping sheets if necessary.
  3. Dust the plastic wrap with a very heavy dusting of half powdered sugar/half corn starch. I use a fine mesh strainer for this.
  4. Set the pan aside.
To Make the Mallows
  1. In the bowl of your stand mixer (at least 5 quart or just make ½ the recipe), pour in the water. Sprinkle the gelatin evenly over the surface along with the salt, instant coffee and optional coffee extract. Let sit for 5 minutes so the gelatin can soften and bloom.
  2. Place the bowl on the mixer fitted with the whip attachment and turn it on low. Let it slowly mix while you do the next steps.
  3. In a medium, heavy-bottomed sauce pan, bring the sugar, corn syrup and about ¼ cup of water slowly to a boil, stirring occasionally to make sure all the sugar is wet.
  4. Once it has come to a boil, slap the lid on and let boil 2-3 minutes to wash down any sugar crystals.
  5. Remove the lid and cook until it reaches 244F. I use my Thermapen
    for this, but you can also buy a candy thermometer that stays in the pan. This will only take a couple of minutes once you take the lid off, so be ready.
  6. Once the sugar syrup reaches 244F, remove the pan from the heat. Turn up the mixer speed to medium-low and carefully stream the sugar syrup into the gelatin mixture.
  7. Let whip at that speed for a minute or two and then turn the speed up to medium and let whip for a minute or two. Once the mixture starts to thicken a bit, turn the speed up to high--be careful. If it's not thick enough, it will slosh out and it's still hot, so go slowly.
  8. Leave the mixer on high speed until the the mixture is very thick and pretty much fills the entire mixing bowl. It will triple in volume and be a very light beige color. Before it gets too thick, taste it and add more instant coffee and/or extract if you think it needs it.
  9. Whip until warm but not hot.
  10. Spray a large spatula with pan spray and scoop all the mallow out into your plastic wrap-lined pan.
  11. Spray the top of the candy with pan spray and use the spatula to spread it as smoothly and as evenly as you can in the pan.
  12. Sift another heavy coat of the powdered sugar/corn starch mixture on top of the mallow and let it sit for several hours or overnight to cure. You can cover it loosely.
  13. When cured, cut your mallows into whatever shapes/sizes you like. I use a pizza cutter that I coat with pan spray, but use what works best for you.
  14. Once cut, toss them all in a bag with powdered sugar/corn starch to cover.
  15. Fish them out and knock off the excess.
  16. If you'd rather, you can press chocolate sprinkles into the cut sides of the mallows rather than tossing them in the powdered sugar mixture. You can also dip the bottoms (or bottom halves) of the mallows into tempered chocolate or coating chocolate and set them on parchment to set up.
  17. I cut my mallows into about ⅓" cubes so they wouldn't be too big for the espresso cups.

I can guarantee you that one sip of this "drinkable dessert" will make memories of even the most humiliating ski outings fade into the background. And if you're an experienced skier, this hot chocolate custard will make a blissfully satisfying end to a perfect day on the slopes.

Hot Chocolate Custard 5

Now that you've had your drinkable dessert first, please take a look at all the other Weekend Ski Party offerings from the talented Progressive Eats crew. If this menu doesn't warm you up, I don't know what will.

progressive eats logo

Join Us for a Weekend Ski Party!




Main Course


Veggies/Side Dishes



Thank you all so much for spending some time cozying up to the fire for Progressive Eats Winter Ski Party event!

Have a lovely day.


All product links are affiliate links. For any sale made through these links, I get a small percentage to help feed the kittens. Your price is unaffected. The cats and I thank you for your support!



  1. says

    Coffee marshmallows? Ultra rich hot custard? I’d be happy to hang out with you in the lodge with one of these babies!
    P.S. My first ski experience sounds EXACTLY like yours–except since I was an Iowan skiing in Wisconsin, many of us were wearing scotchguarded jeans :/

  2. says

    You are braver than I am. I never even went up the slope so got saved from landing on my bottom. Not that I haven’t had “landings” on my bottom in a busy snowy streets (multiple times). Yes, I am that unbalanced. I don’t know how to walk on ice or snow.

    Though I love your hot chocolate custard, it is the marshmallows that will be the weekend project with my teen. She will love it. Thanks for the video.

  3. says

    Oh my heavens Jenni, this is just too much to take in at one shot, I guess I will have to have at least two or three just to make sure I really do like them, ROFL! And you’re not the only one who spent most of their time scooting down the hill instead of skis. After doing fairly well on the bunny slope, I made the mistake of letting my friends talk me into trying a bigger hill. I fell so many times that I gave up, put my skis over my shoulder and walked down! 🙂 I could have really used one of these custards to soothe my frazzled nerves that day! 🙂

  4. says

    I was a die-hard skier for many years – I chose San Francisco over LA solely on the basis that it was closer to decent skiing, and the company I worked for at the time had openings in both cities. I’m so happy you guys all hopped on board for my ski weekend party, and with such gusto. These hot chocolate custards look absolutely amazing. And your video for making marshmallows is wonderful!! I’m skiing tomorrow, and would give a lot to ski down the mountain to one of these.

    • says

      I sometimes wish I knew how to ski, but honestly, I don’t like to be cold! lol I will be more than happy to meet you at the lodge and hand you a steaming cup of hot chocolate custard, Susan! I love this theme, though. Winter Ski Party could just as well mean “comfort food,” and I’m all for that!

  5. says

    This hot chocolate custard looks just dreamy. I’m a chocolohic and would kill to have one or 2 cups of it! Be sure it will soon happen in my kitchen 🙂

    • says

      It is pretty darned fantastic, Sylvie! I hope you enjoy it! It really is especially good with the coffee marshmallows, but if you don’t feel like making them, you could top each little cup with some espresso whipped cream. =)

    • says

      Hi, Jim! Did you see my response on facebook? The short answer is yes, but you’d have to make sure the mallows were really intensely coffee-flavored. And then I guess there’s the issue of do you want gelatin in your cup of coffee, since there’s so much gelatin in mallows? Still, it would be fun to give it a try!


Speak Your Mind

Rate this recipe: