Where Does This Simple Buttercream Recipe Come From?
This buttercream recipe is from The Whimsical Bakehouse by Kaye Hansen and Liv Hansen. It is not based on a sugar syrup, so is easier to make.
What Is So Great About This Buttercream?
In a nutshell, this is what makes this simple buttercream an excellent choice for cake frosting and decorating:
- It holds up very well even on hot days.
- It is easy to make.
- It takes color really well.
- It is neutral in flavor.
I will go on record as saying that I prefer “true” buttercreams (Italian buttercream, French buttercream, etc), but they won’t hold up on a hot day.
Especially if you are frosting a wedding cake for an outdoor wedding, for example, I promise you’ll feel much less stress using simple buttercream than any of the European versions.
While this recipe contains 10X sugar (powdered sugar or icing sugar), the boiling water mostly counteracts that sort of chalky-thing that can happen with this type of sugar.
This buttercream recipe makes kind of a ton, so make sure you have a
Simple Buttercream
This recipe for simple buttercream is from The Whimsical Bakehouse. It makes a generous amount of frosting, and it takes color very well.
Ingredients
- 6 cups sifted 10X sugar
- 1/2 teaspoon salt
- 1 teaspoon vanilla
- 3/4 cup -1 cup of boiling water, (depending on humidity)
- 2 3/4 cups vegetable shortening, (not oil--the solid white kind)
- 6 oz . cool butter, , cut into little pieces
Instructions
- In the bowl of your stand mixer fitted with the whip attachment, stir together the sugar and salt.
- Add the boiling water and whip on medium speed until smooth.
- Add the vanilla, shortening and butter.
- Increase speed to medium-high, and whip until light, fluffy and doubled in volume. This could take 10 or 20 minutes, so be patient.
- Flavor with liqueur or extract. You can try adding chocolate, but I haven't so I'm not sure how good it would be. If you try it, let me know.
Notes
You can try adding chocolate, but I haven't so I'm not sure how good it would be. If you try it, let me know.
Recommended Products
As an Amazon Associate and member of other affiliate programs, I earn from qualifying purchases.
Nutrition Information
Amount Per Serving Calories 563Saturated Fat 14gCholesterol 22mgSodium 151mgCarbohydrates 44gSugar 44g
Looking for a solid cake recipe to use your simple buttercream to frost? Try these:
Stephanie says
Thanks so much for this recipe! I added chocolate and it turned out amazing.
onlinepastrychef says
Hey! Glad it turned out and thank you for letting me know!
Anabel Barbosa says
How much chocolate to add? Melted chocolate? Cocoa powder?
Jennifer Field says
You can add one, the other, or a combination, and it’s all done to taste. So, the short answer is add as much chocolate as you like! My mom always added melted Baker’s unsweetened chocolate, either 2 or 3 “squares” (ounces) per batch of frosting. The liquid she used in the frosting was hot water or milk, but I bet using coffee as the liquid would be great, too.
The whole point of this frosting is that it’s not really a recipe–it’s a technique that you can alter to suit your own tastes, Anabel. I hope you enjoy experimenting!
Monica Rodriguez says
Hi, I love your site and recipes but I am wondering what is meant by 10x sugar? thanks
onlinepastrychef says
Hi! Glad you like the site, Monica! 10x is just another way to say “powdered sugar.” You may also know it as icing sugar. It’s sometimes called 10x because it is processed 10 times to get it to that fine, powdery consistency. 🙂
Monica Rodriguez says
Ok 🙂 thanks a bunch
lisa says
I added cocoa powder and it was delicious. (I also used ganche-equally as delicious). Its very light and almost like mousse filling.
I use 14 oz butter. I found this recipe on another site and the only difference is the amount of butter.
One thing I would like to say however, I tried using the amount of water the recipe calls for and I use hi-ration shortening or store brand shortening (some store brands still have the trans fat, thats what I use) and I find that it comes out way too thinand does not hold up. For this recipe I use only 4 tablespoons or less. What am I doing wrong?
Jennifer Field says
Thanks for the info about the cocoa powder, and I think the ganache idea is amazing! I rarely work with this buttercream anymore. It is mainly up for reference for those who really like this style of buttercream. The few times I have made it, I don’t recall having an issue with consistency. Perhaps you aren’t beating the boiling water mixture until it is below the melting point of shortening/butter so when you add the fat it melts? Try beating it (and holding some ice packs against the bowl to speed things along, until it’s somewhere in the high 70s, temperature-wise. That should be cool enough to keep your fats from melting when you add them.
lisa says
Oh, and I use unsalted butter and I don’t add any salt. I think it tastes much better, but I have to wonder if the omission of salt is why it won’t hold up. though I can’t imagine that it would make a difference,
Jennifer Field says
I can’t imagine that would be the difference because salt doesn’t really bind water. Mysterious, Lisa. :/
Michaela Tidball says
How does this buttercream stand up to heat? I love using the boiling water method as it makes the creamiest frosting but I can’t seem to make it crust or it starts melting halfway through decorating. I use 4 cups of powder sugar, 2 sticks of unsalted butter, 1 cup of palm shortening, and 1/2 cuo boiling water.
Jennifer Field says
It is a pretty stable buttercream, so it should stand up just fine. Crusting buttercream either has cornstarch from the powdered sugar or added meringue powder to allow it to crust. When you use the boiling water, the cornstarch in the sugar probably gelatinizes and won’t crust. If you frosting firms up nicely at refrigerator temps, probably a good chill once the cake is frosted followed by a warm spatula would help to smooth it out.
Andzelika De Leon says
How can I double the receipe?
Jennifer Field says
For this recipe, you can just double all the ingredients and you should have no problem. It does make a lot, so make sure your mixer is large enough to handle a double batch. 🙂