Mexican Hot Chocolate Pie with Snowman Crust Applique
This Mexican Hot Chocolate Pie is absolutely decadent and delicious. Add to it the cute snowman crust applique, and you have a new classic Christmas pie!
The marshmallows keep this from being vegetarian. It's a simple swap from marshmallows to sprinkles though to keep it vegetarian.
You can use store-bought crust for this. You'll need 1 crust for the bottom and about 1/2 of another for the applique. I made Stella's recipe from Serious Eats. So goodand you don't need a recipe since the formula is so easy to remember.
For the Filling
2oz1/2 stick unsalted butter, melted
10.5ozbrown sugar(light or dark is just fine)
3large eggs
¾teaspoonkosher salt(or about 1/2 teaspoon fine salt)
Preheat the oven to 350F and set a rack in the middle of the oven. Place a baking stone on the rack.
For the Crust
Line a 9" regular pie pan with one of the crusts. Trim to within 3/4 inches of the edge of the pan. Fold excess underneath to make a double thickness and crimp however you like.
For the Filling
In a large bowl, whisk together all the filling ingredients until smooth.
To Finish and Bake
With a small offset spatula, spread the marshmallow cream in a thin, even layer across the bottom of the pie shell. It may fight with you a bit, but don't worry. You will win. I know it.
Pour in the batter evenly on top of the marshmallow cream and shake the pan a bit to level it out. Brush the crust with egg wash.
Place the pie in the oven on the stone and set the timer for 25 minutes.
While the pie is baking, cut out all your pieces. First, roll your dough a bit to make it fairly thin. For the snowman, you'll need a large circle and a smaller circle, a rectangle shape for the hat, a long, skinny rectangle for the brim, a triangle for the nose and 3 free-form pieces for the scarf and "tails."
If using sprinkles, pour them out into onto a small plate and brush each piece you want covered in sprinkles in egg wash. Then press the pieces, egg wash side down, into the sprinkles so they adhere.
Cut out eyes and buttons with the back of a piping tip. You can also glue on circles rather than cutting them out. Your call.
Attach the pieces together with water. Leave the scarf tails to be placed after you place the snowman.
When the timer goes off, carefully remove the pie from the oven. Place the applique using a large spatula. Attach the scarf tails with a bit of water.
Put the pie back in the oven and bake until the pie is well risen and firm, another 20 minutes or so.
Add mini marshmallows for snow if you'd like. Let the marshmallows melt on the pie for a minute or two and then put them under the broiler for a minute until they puff up. (If you don't want to use the mini marshmallows, use your favorite snowflake sprinkles instead. Or leave them off entirely.)
Roll the dough for the appliques much thinner than you would for regular pie crust. They will be baking only half as long, and you want them to crisp up all the way through, so roll them about half as thick as "normal" pie crust--about 1/16".
Use plain water to "glue" pieces of your applique together.
I assembled the main parts: body, head, piece of scarf that goes around the neck, hat, and brim first before placing it on the pie.
You don't need to glue the applique down to the pie itself. You only need to glue the pieces together (again, with water). I placed the tails of the scarf once I had the snowman where I wanted him.
You can keep the assembled applique in the fridge until you're ready to place it on the pie.
Brush the whole applique (except the parts you covered with sprinkles) with a thin coat of egg wash before placing back in the oven.
I used graduated cutters to cut out the rounds for the snowman. I used the base of a piping tip to cut out the eyes and buttons. I free-handed the nose, scarf, hat, and brim just using a knife.
I baked the pie for 25 minutes before adding the applique pieces. Then I baked an additional 22 minutes (your time might vary) until the filling was well puffed and firm on top.
The marshmallow cream sort of bubbled up through the filling in a few places and gave a feeling of snow. I added the marshmallows after baking, let them melt into the pie for a couple of minutes, and then finished them under the broiler for 1 minute.
If you don't want big honking marshmallow snowflakes, you could use these instead.
Bake the pie on a preheated baking stone to ensure the bottom crust bakes up nice and crisp, even without blind baking.
How to Coat Pieces in Sprinkles
To completely coat a piece in sprinkles like I did for the scarf (which was composed of three pieces I glued together after dipping):
brush on a thin coat of egg wash
dip the egg washed side into a plateful of your desired sprinkles
press the piece gently into the sprinkles to encourage them to adhere.
How to Cleanly Slice Your Pie
To get the cleanest possible slices, start each cut with the tip of a sharp knife and just cut down all along the slice you’re cutting–no sawing motion.When you have cut through all the top crust cleanly, you can go back and drag your knife through continuously to make sure the slice is free before serving.I was a little concerned it would be a pain to slice, and while I did have to take more-than-usual care, the process was easier than I’d anticipated, and the cut slices look really good.