Looking for deep, rich butterscotch flavor in your butterscotch cheesecake? Stick with me, because I’m going to teach you how!
We are talking deeply rich butterscotch cheesecake batter baked up and then topped with a beautiful brown sugar Swiss meringue. The butterscotch goodness doesn’t get much better than that!
Find more butterscotch recipes here.
This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Your price is unaffected. For more information, please see our disclosure policy.
For Butterscotch Lovers Only
Butterscotch has a deliciously complex flavor that only requires three ingredients.
Butterscotch happens when you cook butter and dark brown sugar together with a bit of salt until the sugar has caramelized and the butter has browned.
Think you don’t like butterscotch? Well, do you like toffee? That crunchy, nutty goodness often topped with chocolate?
If your answer is YES, then you like butterscotch. And you’re going to want o make this cheesecake.
Most people think they don’t like butterscotch because they’ve never had real, homemade butterscotch. If you fall into that category, please stick with me. I want to change your mind about butterscotch!
Why Not Make This Cheesecake with Butterscotch Pudding Mix?
You could make butterscotch cheesecake with pudding mix, but boxed butterscotch pudding isn’t real butterscotch. I’m honestly not sure what it is. But it’s not butterscotch.
Here are the ingredients in boxed, cook and serve butterscotch pudding:
- Modified Cornstarch
Contains less than 2% of the following:
- Natural and Artificial Flavor
- Polysorbate 60 (Prevents Scorching)
- Calcium Carrageenan (Thickener)
- Yellow 5
- Red 40
- Blue 1
Now, far be it from me to say that any of those ingredients is inherently bad. I’m just saying I see no brown sugar and no butter. And without those 2 ingredients, you can’t have real butterscotch. Period.
Butterscotch Sauce, Times Two
This butterscotch cheesecake gets its butterscotchiness from real, homemade butterscotch sauce added both to the cheesecake mix and drizzled on (or spooned over) the cake.
Since brown sugar is one of the two main flavor components in butterscotch, I made a brown sugar Swiss meringue to top it off. The texture of the creamy, dense cheesecake contrasts beautifully with the light and poofy meringue.
Both the cheesecake and the meringue are set off by a crunchy gluten-free crust made of gluten-free rolled oats, mixed nuts, a touch of brown sugar and some butter.
Crunchy, creamy, poofy plus a bit of gooey from the butterscotch sauce topping, and you can see what a perfect bite of goodness you’re getting!
What If I Want to Make Butterscotch Cheesecake Bars?
How To Make This Cheesecake, Step by Step
Make the first Butterscotch Sauce Cook butter and brown sugar together along with some salt. Stop the cooking process by adding heavy cream. Cool to warm.
Make and Bake the Crust Whir all the crust ingredients together in a food processor. Press into your springform pan or push pan and bake at 350F for 10-12 minutes.
Make the Cheesecake Batter Mix cream cheese until smooth. Add the warm sauce 1/3 at a time, blending well. Add the eggs, one at a time. Blend in the vanilla.
Bake the Cheesecake in a Water Bath Wrap the cooled pan in two layers of foil. Pour in the cheesecake batter and smooth the top.
Place the cheesecake in a larger pan and add boiling water to come about halfway up the sides of the pan. Bake at 325F until done. You’re looking for an internal temperature of 1565F.
The center will still be a bit jiggly, but the edges will be set. Depending on your oven, this could take anywhere from an hour to an hour and a half.
Cool and Chill Turn off the oven, prop the door open, and cool the cake, still in the water bath, for an hour before removing to a rack to cool to just warm. Refrigerate for at least 6 hours.
Make the Swiss Meringue In the bowl of your stand mixer set over a pan of simmering water, whisk egg whites, brown sugar, and a pinch of salt together until the temperature reaches 180F.
Once it’s there, put the mixing bowl on your mixer. Use the whisk attachment to whisk the meringue until it is billowy, poofy, and holds firm peaks that just bend over into sexy swoops.
Apply Meringue to Cheesecake and Torch Spread the meringue all over the top of the cake, then pick your spatula straight up, causing big swoopy peaks to form.
Do this all over the surface of your cake until you like the way it looks.
Use your kitchen torch to brown your meringue Dramatically.
If you don’t have a torch, you can do this under the broiler for 2-3 minutes, turning the cake at least once. Just watch it carefully so you don’t burn it.
- Make the Second Butterscotch Sauce for Serving Ditto step 1. The sauce will cool to a solid, and it’ll definitely get Very Solid in the fridge, so reheat gently and stir well before serving.
How Long Will This Cheesecake Stay “Good?”
Keep the whole cake and any uneaten cake covered in the fridge. The meringue may start to get soft after a couple of days, but the whole thing will be fine to eat for 4-5 days after baking.
I doubt it will last that long.
But Seriously, Bake This Cake in a Water Bath
Let me tell you a very short story.
I used the recipe for regular cheesecake from Junior’s as my starting point for butterscotch cheesecake.
Their cheesecake recipe calls for it to be baked in a 350F oven without a water bath. Now, normally, I would never NOT use a water bath.
But I believed Junior.
The recipe says that because it contains starch, it keeps the eggs from curdling. And that’s true.
But what it does not do is keep the eggs from souffleeing, or rising up and then falling once it cools.
Cheesecake batter is very wet, and it generates a lot of steam. That steam pushes the batter up, up, up. Then it collapses down, down, down, leaving a weird crater in the middle of your cake. Not so great.
In the photo above, you can see that this happened in my cake. A perfect cheesecake should have a lovely, flat top. Mine has Topography. Unwanted Topography. And while the texture did not suffer, the look of the cake definitely did.
Bake your cake in a water bath. The hot water will never get above 212F (at sea level), because that’s boiling point. And it will stay at the boiling point until all the water is gone. And that will take a lot longer than the time it takes your cake to bake.
Using a water bath keeps the sides of the cake cooler–212F at sea level, to be exact–so that they set at about the same rate as the rest of the cake, allowing for a lovely, flat surface.
Yes, it takes longer to bake. But do it, especially if you want to serve your cake minimally garnished, or maybe with just a thin slick of butterscotch sauce over the top as opposed to the meringue.
Is the Whole Cheesecake Gluten-Free? Not Just the Crust, Right?
Yes! The cheesecake filling contains:
- homemade butterscotch sauce (dark brown sugar, butter, salt, heavy cream)
- cream cheese
- corn starch
- And the crust ingredients are:
- gluten free rolled oats
- salted mixed nuts (check your labels to make sure. Mine are gf)
- dark brown sugar
The meringue is egg whites, dark brown sugar, salt, and vanilla. So yes, the whole butterscotch cheesecake extravaganza is gluten-free.
It is not, however, calorie-free. Like at all.
More Gluten-Free Cheesecake Recipes
- Gluten-Free Pumpkin Cheesecake
- Mini Gluten-Free Pineapple Upside Down Cheesecakes
- Gluten-Free Death by Chocolate Cheesecake
For more cheesecake resources and recipes, please check out my Cheesecake Recipes page.
Other Butterscotch Posts on Pastry Chef Online
Wondering what butterscotch is? I can help.
And read on to find out what the difference is between butterscotch and caramel.
I really hope you love this butterscotch cheesecake recipe, you guys! If you make it, please share a photo with me, either in the PCO Facebook Group or on instagram by tagging @onlinepastrychef and using hashtag #pcorecipe. Thanks, and enjoy!
For the Crust
- 1/2 cup gluten free rolled oats
- 3/4 cup mixed salted nuts (or 3/4 cup of your favorite toasted nut/s)
- pinch of salt (I use Morton's kosher salt)
- 3 Tablespoons dark brown sugar
- 3 Tablespoons cold butter
For the Cheesecake
- 11 oz dark brown sugar (1 1/3 cups, packed)
- 4 oz unsalted butter (1 stick)
- 1/2 teaspoon kosher salt (I use Morton's)
- 6 oz heavy cream (3/4 cup)
- 24 oz full fat cream cheese (3 8oz blocks), at room temperature
- 2 large eggs, at room temperature
- 1 teaspoon vanilla extract or paste
For the Brown Sugar Meringue
- 3 large egg whites
- 6 oz dark brown sugar (generous 3/4 cup, packed)
- heavy pinch of salt
- 1/2 teaspoon vanilla extract or paste
For the Butterscotch Sauce
- 3 oz unsalted butter (6 Tablespoons or 3/4 stick)
- 4 oz dark brown sugar (1/2 cup, packed)
- 1/4 teaspoon kosher salt (I use Morton's)
- 6 oz heavy cream (3.4 cup)
To Make the Crust
- Line the bottom of a springform pan with a parchment circle. Spray the sides with pan spray. Wrap the bottom of the pan in two thicknesses of heavy duty aluminum foil. Preheat your oven to 350F.
- Put the rolled oats, nuts, salt, and dark brown sugar into the bowl of your food processor. Process in pulses until fairly finely ground, but don't overprocess and end up with mixed nut butter.
- Cut the butter into pieces and scatter them into the bowl. Pulse to combine.
- Press evenly into the bottom of your 8" springform pan.
- Bake for 10-12 minutes and remove from oven. Allow to cool at least 30 minutes before adding the cheesecake batter.
To Make the Cheesecake Batter
- First make the butterscotch: in a medium, heavy-bottomed saucepan, heat the butter over medium heat until about halfway melted. Add the dark brown sugar and salt and stir well. Continue to heat, stirring constantly, until the butter has all melted and the sugar has dissolved. Not all will dissolve because there isn't enough water in that small amount of butter to dissolve all the sugar. That's okay. Keep cooking and stirring, raising the heat to medium-high, until the sugar starts to caramelize. You'll smell that distinctive "burned sugar" smell and probably see some smoke rising from the pot. Stir for another few seconds, then carefully pour in the cream and remove from the heat. Whisk well until as smooth as you can get it. Strain through a fine mesh strainer to catch any bits of sugar crystals.Set aside to cool until warm, stirring occasionally to further cool it, about 30-45 minutes.
- Preheat oven to 325F and put a large pot or kettle of water on to boil.
- Put the softened blocks of cream cheese into a large bowl. Mix with your hand mixer until smooth.
- Pour in about 1/3 of the butterscotch and blend until smooth, scraping bowl as necessary.
- Add the rest in two more additions, mixing in between on medium speed.
- Add the eggs, one at a time, and blend well, scraping bowl as needed.
- Blend in the vanilla and scrape the bowl while folding the batter together really well.
- Pour into the prepared pan and smooth the top.
- Place the pan into a larger roasting pan and put into the oven. Pour in boiling water to come halfway up the sides of the springform pan (about 1 1/2").
- Bake until the cheesecake is deep golden brown on top and is set completely around the edges with just a bit of a jiggle in the center. You're looking for an internal temperature of 165F. This will take anywhere from 1 to 1 1/2 hours, depending on your oven.
- Turn off the oven and crack open the door. Let the cake cool in the water bath for about an hour. Then remove to cool completely on a cooling rack. Chill at least 6 hours.
To Make the Meringue
- Put the three egg whites, the sugar, and the salt into your stand mixer bowl. Bring about 1" of water to a boil in a pot that it big enough to let the mixer bowl sit down inside it but not so big that the bottom of the bowl touches the water.
- Keep the water at a high simmer, and heat the whites, whisking constantly, until the mixture has thinned out, is no longer grainy, and registers 180F on an instant read thermometer.
- Take the bowl off the heat and attach it to your mixer.
- Whip until the meringue holds glossy, stiff peaks that bend over sexily. Scrape the bowl a couple of times while whipping to make sure all your whites whip up beautifully.
- Spread the meringue on top of the chilled cake and lift up with your spatula to make dramatic swoops and curls all over the top. Stop when you like how it looks.
- Use your kitchen torch to brown the meringue as much as you like. You can also do this under your broiler for 2-3 minutes, turning the cake at least once and watching it carefully so the meringue doesn't burn.
To Make the Butterscotch Sauce
- Follow the butterscotch-making rules above using 3 oz butter, 4 oz dark brown sugar, 1/4 teaspoon of salt and adding 6 oz heavy cream once the sugar caramelizes. Stir over low heat until smooth.
- Since this butterscotch has proportionally more butter than the first one, you should not have to deal with any sugar crystals. if you do end up with some, just strain them out.
- Use a hot knife to slice the cake into 12 serving. The servings will look small, but this is a whole lot of cheesecake going on, so 1/12 of this cake should be sufficient as a serving. Serve with the sauce drizzled over the top, swooshed onto the plate, or however you like. Note the butterscotch will cool, into a soft candy that won't run, but it will be easy to eat and to cut with the side of your fork when you eat.
To Make Butterscotch Cheesecake Bars, increase the crust amounts to 3/4 cup oats, 1 cup, mixed nuts, 4 T dark brown sugar, 4 T butter and a heavy pinch of salt. Press into the bottom of a 9 x 13" pan.
You will not have to adjust the amount of filling. The bars will not bake up as tall as the cheesecake, but that's fine since you're making bars. Rather than topping with meringue, consider topping them with a thin layer of butterscotch sauce or even swirling some of the "second butterscotch" into the batter before baking.
Nutirionals are based on 1/12 of the whole cake and are calculated for that and not for bars.
As an Amazon Associate and member of other affiliate programs, I earn from qualifying purchases.
Nutrition InformationYield 12 Serving Size 1/12
Amount Per Serving Calories 739 Total Fat 52.8g Saturated Fat 29.9g Trans Fat 0g Unsaturated Fat 12g Cholesterol 173mg Sodium 562mg Carbohydrates 55.3g Fiber 0.7g Sugar 51g Protein 8.4g
And there you have it friends. Enjoy the cheesecake, whether or not you’re gluten-free. We’re not, and we loved every bite!
Thanks for spending some time with me today. Take care, and have a lovely day.